When deciding between vinyl and fiber cement siding, many homeowners may instinctively feel that fiber cement siding is the right choice for their home due to its composition, materials, and engineering. But if you want to make an informed decision for the ultimate protection of your home, you wouldn’t want to jump to conclusions quickly. Instead, you would want to know all about the differences between vinyl and fiber cement siding.
Therefore, we’ve created this blog post on fiber cement siding vs. vinyl siding, to provide you with all the information you need to make an informed decision. Keep reading to learn all about the pros and cons of each material, the cost of installation, and the different installation methods used.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement is considered the most durable and long-lasting siding material in the industry. It has stood the test of time with its extraordinary weather and impact resistance. Made of Portland cement, water, sand, and cellulose fibers, fiber cement siding is thick, low maintenance, and lasts for decades.
In contrast to wood siding, fiber cement siding is fire and rot-resistant, and handles temperature fluctuations well. This resistance to temperature change prevents warping and maintains the siding’s aesthetic appeal over time. You’ll also find that these siding panels come in numerous styles, looks, and textures.
If you want to invest in siding that lasts longer than any other siding on the market, fiber cement siding is the right choice for you.
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding is the most popular and affordable type of siding on the market. It comes in numerous colors and styles to meet the architectural appeal of the building it is installed on. Made of durable materials, PVC, and other additives, vinyl siding maintains its aesthetic appeal and can be installed easily.
In fact, if you are going to install vinyl siding on your home, you won’t have to invest as much money into the material as you would to install fiber cement siding. Vinyl siding also lasts longer if it’s installed correctly by professional installers.
The siding is installed in panels that interlock with one another, giving it robust resistance, and a seamless look.
Fiber Cement vs. Vinyl: The Differences Between The Two
1. Aesthetic Appeal
a) Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement boards are known for being able to provide the authentic look of wood or cedar, providing depth to the exterior of any home. Fiber cement siding comes in various textures and finishes, including traditional clapboard, cedar shake, and stucco, offering homeowners various options to choose from.
b) Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding is known for its versatility in styles and colors. Most brands provide a palette of extensive colors and style options that match any architectural structure. Apart from this, vinyl siding can also mimic the texture and style of other siding materials, including metal and wood. While being the most affordable siding option, vinyl siding allows you to express your taste and standards.
Winner – While both fiber cement and vinyl siding have come a long way in providing homes with a distinctive look and appeal, vinyl siding wins for its versatility and ability to mimic other siding materials.
2. Durability And Longevity
a) Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding is the most robust siding on the market. With a combination of fibers, Portland cement, water, and sand, this siding is resistant to impacts, pests, and fire. So, if you prioritize longevity and want a siding material that can stand the test of time, fiber cement siding is an excellent choice for you.
b) Vinyl Siding
While not as durable as fiber cement siding, vinyl siding has its own durability. Made of PVC, vinyl siding can last over 20 years if the panels are maintained properly. However, though the material is less expensive, vinyl siding can become damaged over time due to forceful impacts, and crack and fade over time.
Winner – Between the two, fiber cement siding wins. Since the material can withstand forceful impacts without showing any cracks, or wear and tear, it stands out as more durable than vinyl siding.
3. Energy Efficiency
a) Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding is known for its dense, thick, and solid composition, which, in itself, acts as a natural insulator. While it may not be as energy-efficient as some specialized insulation materials, it does contribute positively to your home’s thermal performance.
b) Insulated Vinyl Siding
Some vinyl siding products are engineered with energy efficiency in mind. Insulated vinyl siding features a layer of foam insulation beneath the panels which significantly improves your home’s thermal performance.
Winner – Vinyl siding is the winner, particularly insulated vinyl siding. The added layer of insulation has a positive impact in terms of increasing your home’s energy efficiency.
4. Maintenance And Upkeep
a) Fiber Cement Siding
Due to its outstanding durability and longevity, the chances of your fiber cement siding becoming damaged are less than other siding options. This makes this siding material low maintenance. However, you may need to paint and recoat the siding to ensure its protection and aesthetic appeal.
b) Vinyl Siding
While vinyl siding is easier to maintain, it may need frequent maintenance, as it can be damaged due to many environmental factors. There may also come a time when you need to clean vinyl siding with a garden hose.
Winner – We can’t neglect the fact that siding, whether fiber cement or vinyl, needs maintenance and upkeep to keep it functional for years. However, fiber cement siding beats out vinyl siding, which needs more upkeep.
5. Cost Of Installation
a) Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding is one of the most durable siding materials in the siding industry. It is thick, and for this reason, it can be expensive to install and maintain. Fiber cement siding is the right choice for homeowners who have a higher price range and also want long-lasting siding panels.
b) Vinyl Siding
Compared to fiber cement siding, vinyl siding is the most popular siding option for homeowners who have a tight budget. However, while the installation and material cost of vinyl siding is more affordable upfront, you may be paying more for frequent maintenance or repairs over time.
Winner – While cement siding is more expensive upfront, it proves to be the right choice in the long run.
Which Is Better, Fiber Cement Siding or Vinyl Siding?
Homeowners want their siding to stand out while also blending with their desired architectural design. Both fiber cement and vinyl siding are great options to provide homes with a unique and distinctive look. However, you also need to consider the following factors before making the right decision.
1. Prioritize Your Needs
What do you want from your siding the most? Is it durability? Longevity? Affordability or low maintenance? Ask yourself these questions before finalizing your decision. Then, considering these factors, determine which siding satisfies your needs.
If you want durable and low-maintenance siding on your home, then, fiber cement siding is the right choice for you. Or, if you have a limited budget, vinyl siding is a great option. However, it all comes down to your preference.
2. Aesthetic Preference
Many homeowners with a tight budget still want aesthetically pleasing siding for their homes. Luckily, both siding materials provide various options to choose from that provide a natural and authentic look that homeowners will love.
3. Long-Term Goals
Consider your long-term goals for your home. Are you planning to stay for many years, or is this a short-term investment? Fiber cement siding can be a long-term investment due to its initial expense, durability, and its potential to increase your home’s value over time.
4. Consult With Professionals
Seek advice from siding professionals who can evaluate your home’s specific needs and provide expert guidance. They can provide accurate estimates, assess your location, and recommend the best siding material based on your priorities.
Turn To Clear Cut Xteriors In Minneapolis For Your Home Siding Needs!
Clear Cut Xteriors is one of the best and most skilled, roofing and home exterior service providers in the state. Our company has years of experience in siding replacement in Minneapolis, so contact us today at (651)-340-3410 and consult with one of our siding installation and replacement professionals.
